Deviant Login Shop  Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour
×

:iconfullwhitemoon: More from FullWhiteMoon


More from deviantART



Details

Submitted on
May 27, 2010
Link
Thumb

Stats

Views
7,960 (11 today)
Favourites
105 (who?)
Comments
411
×
Assalamu alaikum (Peace be upon you)

Dear brothers, sisters and friends,

From time to time, we hear in the news that somebody made a drawing of the prophet Mohammed (peace be upon him) and so many muslims around the world got angry, complained and didn't like it. some of you (non-muslims) may ask "Why muslims are so sensitive? it's just a drawing. it could be anyone" or "Why when we draw somebody else, no one complains and when we draw Mohammed, all Muslims don't like it?" and so many other questions. here I'll try to make it clear for those who want to know why we get angry when our prophet is drawn.

first, I want you to know that representing our prophet in art is not the real problem. we, muslims, don't draw our prophet, out of respect. because no matter how good the artist is, he can never depict the prophet like he was. so the drawing will never be faithful. so it's considered a lie about the prophet (since the drawing is different from how he really looked like). and we are not allowed to lie about our prophet. so muslims can't draw or represent the prophet (our prophet or any other prophet)
there are some muslims who have a different opinion. they think that representing the prophet is not forbidden as long as the representation is respectful and not insulting. those muslims try to make a respectful representation of the prophet(s) in their art. this can be accepted as long as it doesn't offend anyone.

now for non-muslims. we can't expect from them to respect our prophet the way we do. but what we see from time to time, is that some people depict the prophet Mohammed.
the real question is : "Why is it that all these depictions are always done for the purpose of insulting the prophet and Islam?" "why they always want to make fun of him and show him in a bad way?" "why we don't see any respectful drawings of the prophet done by non-muslims? why all of them are disrespectful?" it's obvious, all those who draw the prophet want to insult him and Islam. there is no muslim who complains about respectful drawings of the prophet. but when someone draws our prophet in a shameful way to make fun of him or link him to terrorism, making him as an ugly cartoon character or something like that, we don't like it. and we have the right no to like it. if someone insults your father, will you like it? if you love your father, you'll certainly not. then know that our prophet is dearer to us than our fathers.

We muslims don't draw and make fun of any religious symbols either ours or not. you can't find any disrespectful drawing of Jesus Christ, Moses, Buddha or any other religious person drawn by muslims. we don't make fun or insult other people's beliefs. we respect everyone's belief. and we ask the same from others: respect our belief and religious symbols.

we don't like when someone insults our beloved prophet and calls it freedom of speech. everyone is free to express his opinion considering that he/she respects the beliefs of others and doesn't offend them. most people confuse between "hate speech" and "freedom of speech". what we see in the media is hate toward Islam. those people who draw the prophet didn't even bother to read a little about him and his life. we have in Islam some very good descriptions of how the prophet looked like. and all those disgusting drawings are far from that description because those who drew them don't know anything about Islam. and when we complain, they answer that this is freedom. Is insulting others freedom? is making fun of others' beliefs freedom? is spreading hatred freedom? is spreading lies and war freedom? this is wrong. totally wrong. why? there are so many ways how you can express your opinion with others without hurting and offending them. there are so many civilized ways to disagree with others. and still letting them like you and respect you. if you want to talk about our prophet. it's fine. but don't spread baseless lies to fool people.

another thing to notice. those people who draw bad drawings to insult the prophet Mohammed, all of them share the same thing: they like to insult others when they feel weak. you may ask why I say so? it's simple, go and enter in a debate with any one of them to explain the truth and you see how low their language can go. this shows that those people are the worst of the worst (we shouldn't call them artists since an artist has a high duty and message and should spread peace and not hate)


There is one proverb that says "no one will kick a dead dog" if you are not important, nobody will bother to bring you troubles. but if you are important, people will try their best to bring you down. if Mohammed peace be upon him was not great, no one would bother to try to insult him. but since he is one of the greatest men in history (some of you may disagree about this. but let's face facts. a man who wins the hearts of more than a billion people around the world is a great man. right?). there are so many people who tried/try/will try uselessly to bring down his reputation by spreading lies and insults. this doesn't happen simply because his love is always lit in the hearts of millions of muslims around the world. those who draw insulting drawings of the prophet get some attention and hate in a short time and then they will always end up forgotten by the world. and in the end, the prophet Mohammed still keeps the same high place in the heart of those who love him. look at all great artists in history. they drew subjects far from hate. and that's what made them famous and great.

There are limits to freedom. and its limits are when you insult other people's freedom, rights and faiths. you have the right to express your opinion but without offending others. when you learn and understand this, you will be a great human being. when you insult others whenever you open your mouth, nobody will like you and nobody will listen to you seriously... as an artist, you can choose a peaceful way to spread your message and be loved by the people... or a hateful way to spread it and get hate from the people...


May God bless you,

Assalamu alaikum (peace be upon you)
DD
Add a Comment:
 
:iconthewritersnotebook:
Dude, I just wanted to know why South Park can't show mohammed and I find all this?
Anyway, I kind of agree with some things you're saying, but with other things I disagree.
I agree with the fact that freedom of speech shouldn't mean you can just insult others if you want to: that is cruel and wrong, and shouldn't be called freedom of speech. If you allow people to mindlessly insult others, than that is freedom of insulting and that shouldn't exist.
However, I think saying drawing Mohammed in the 'wrong' way is insulting isn't right. I know it shouldn't be right to just draw whatever you want, and I understand some people may take offense of it, but nobody actually means to insult your faith and you and everyone else out there KNOWS it. When knowing nobody means harm, there shouldn't be such a big deal.
Also, It's kind of bad how you can care more about a dead profit (is that how you write it? sorry) then about your own father. Sure, you should care in the man who has changed your life (hopefully for the better), but isn'tit actually a thing that your family should be respected by you and imporant to you? I'm not sure if that's actually what you're faith says, but I do think it is... You can correct me if I'm wrong, I don't mind learning something new.
I mean, if you care more about a man who you didn't even personally know than about your own father, it's just a little bit weird (I really don't mean to insult anyone, it can be how you feel and I totally understand it if it is, everyone has different feelings, I'm just expressing my thoughts here). I mean, if I go around saying: "You know, I care more about Micheal Jackson than I care about my mother (untrue, just making an example.... probably a sucky one)" than people would start yelling and telling me how wrong that is.
However, don't take me wrong. I do understand that showing mohammed in a way to just joke about him can be very offensive. I was just really wondering WHY it's so offensive because when it comes down to it he was just a person like veryone else, even if he might have done some special things.
Reply
:iconmirakhall:
MiraKHall Dec 11, 2013   General Artist
Just because someone insults my mother doesn't mean I have the right to kill someone on the spot.

I'm sorry, but responding to ANYTHING with violence is not okay, and like it or not, no one is protected from being insulted, no matter how wrong they may be.  Just because a written law from centuries ago is declared law doesn't mean every free-willed human being is going to follow it without a little bit of worldly education, something we lack terribly in the U.S., I ll admit :X (thank goodness for community college).  A picture of a prophet, flattering or not, is nothing to be concerned about, and just as easily ignorable as turning off the TV... or not bother watching South Park anymore.  If the prophet WERE to be reborn in one form or another and then killed on the spot by non-believers, I think that would be justifiable demand for restitution.  It's like mucking up the oceans with new-found underground oil once more after cleaning up the previous mess BP left.

If you believe that the prophet drawn as a terrorist is not the true prophet at all, isn't it all that really matters?  Isn't denouncing false statements just as powerful as declaring your shahada?
Reply
:iconvery-random-name:
"There are limits to freedom. and its limits are when you insult other people's freedom, rights and faiths."

I disagree. The ability to speak in a way that some view as insulting (barring slander and fraud) is part and parcel of the right to free speech. And it happens all the time. Books are published all the time that people find insulting to thier faith. That sort of open dialogue is important in a society.
Reply
:iconvanpablo79:
a dead pedophile warrior is more important to you than your father.
religion is an insult to humanity.
Reply
:iconstrixcz:
StrixCZ Jul 13, 2011  Hobbyist General Artist
"There are limits to freedom. and its limits are when you insult other people's freedom, rights and faiths."

The tricky part of this is: Where do you make the line between what's considered insulting and what is not? :idea:

It's always in your head, depending strictly on how touchy you are.

One way or another, reacting to or getting mad about someone making fun of what you consider forbidden to be made fun of doesn't help anything. Even in cases where's it's quite clear that someone's not just "harmlessly joking" but he's actually trying to spread hate - reacting to hate means spreading more hate so you getting angry about it is just what he's aiming for, don't you understand...?

Moreover, since you consider people who make fun of Mohammed or portray him in a disrespectful way "worst of the worst", I wonder why you even care about opinions and actions of such people? Seems like they're not "dead dogs" to you after all - because your caring about them and getting mad because of what they say and do is the single most important thing that makes them noticed and in a way - famous.

:peace:
Reply
:icondoransig:
So I'm not particularly sure what kind of action you want taken against these people who draw images you don't like.
Yes, I agree with you that drawing something to intentionally offend people is bad, but what can be done? You have not stated what kind of consequences these people should face (if any).
Reply
:iconladysugarquill:
ladysugarquill Dec 29, 2010  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
I liked your article. I'm a Christian, and I too am annoyed at people being disrespectful assholes and then hiding behind "freedom of speech". Yes, they're free to be assholes. But we're free to call them on their assholyness (is that a word? Well, now it is XD).
Reply
:iconjiehahnajihah:
jiehahnajihah Dec 23, 2010  Student General Artist
i love this!
Reply
:iconevlnabiki:
Everything in Islam has a reason for telling us to do so and so. Some reasons are glaringly obvious. Some of them require a wee bit of thinking. Some reasons us humans have yet to uncover. But nevertheless, there is a reason. Why we are forbidden to have art of the Prophet {PBUH} also has a very simple reason in hindsight, though the conclusion may be a bit hard to reach when one thinks of it for the first time. Humans are fickle creatures. Our thinking gets twisted from time to time, and when some types of traditions, such as religious ones are passed down, there is a big risk of them being slightly changed each time, so that the end result is the like the one for a game of chinese whispers: extremely convoluted. Now suppose someone was able to capture the Prophet's likeness {PBUH}, nevermind the fact that no one can. From one generation to the next, that painting will be passed down, and revered, as it rightly should be, as it is a painting of the Prophet. However, somewhere down the line, there is a great chance that that painting will start to be treated like an idol. People will worship that painting, and pray to it as well, instead of praying solely to Allah, as is what we have been commanded to do. This is wrong for us. That is not what Islam asks us to do when we read the Shahadah, when we become Muslims, what we live our lives by. And therefore, we shall be sinning. To stop us from ever falling into that trap, it was made wrong for us to ever make a painting or drawing or sculpture, or any sort of likeness of the Prophet. He forbade it for that very reason in his lifetime, and we forbid it in our lifetimes as well. As for someone non-Muslim making drawings of the Prophet... all we ask is for you to respect him, and respect us. After doing that, do whatever you feel in your heart is right, and I don't think we could ask for much more.
Reply
Add a Comment: